Oxicloud/tools/perf-audit/results/admin-user-index-representative-postgres18-macos-arm64.json

{
  "schemaVersion": 1,
  "generatedAt": "2026-07-22",
  "benchmark": "admin user created_at index representative cost gate",
  "environment": {
    "platform": "darwin",
    "arch": "arm64",
    "cpu": "Apple M4 Pro",
    "postgresImage": "postgres:18.2-alpine3.23",
    "container": "oxicloud-postgres-1",
    "client": "psql through docker exec"
  },
  "method": {
    "rowsPerDistribution": 500000,
    "independentTransactions": 3,
    "samplesPerTransactionAndShape": 5,
    "totalSamplesPerShape": 15,
    "warmupsPerTransactionAndShape": 1,
    "order": "A/B for the accepted timestamp-only result; a later A/B/C gate rotated no-index/simple/compound order inside every transaction",
    "harnessEvolution": "the current representative SQL is the expanded A/B/C version; the top-level distribution samples retain the earlier A/B authorization run, while compoundRepresentativeABC retains the later isolated rerun",
    "cleanup": "every transaction ended in ROLLBACK",
    "commonIndexes": "both baseline and candidate tables have the same UUID primary-key index",
    "insertBatchRows": 10000,
    "insertValues": "prebuilt identical A/B batches with new timestamps and an indexed sample selector"
  },
  "previousTiedFixtureComparison": {
    "timestampMultiplicity": 100,
    "indexBytes": 3448832,
    "uniqueToTiedIndexByteRatio": 3.263,
    "reasonForFollowup": "PostgreSQL posting-list deduplication compressed repeated created_at keys and understated a normal mostly-unique registration workload"
  },
  "uniqueTimestamps": {
    "distinctTimestamps": 500000,
    "indexBytesEachRound": [
      11255808,
      11255808,
      11255808
    ],
    "indexBytesPerInitialUser": 22.512,
    "indexBytesAfter50000InsertsEachRound": [
      13271040,
      13271040,
      13271040
    ],
    "firstPage": {
      "noIndexSamplesMs": [
        98.496,
        121.451,
        98.425,
        81.049,
        94.833,
        57.602,
        62.54,
        56.785,
        56.918,
        55.854,
        57.217,
        57.131,
        54.457,
        56.319,
        56.651
      ],
      "indexSamplesMs": [
        0.459,
        0.454,
        0.242,
        0.207,
        0.215,
        0.287,
        0.208,
        0.225,
        0.14,
        0.2,
        0.232,
        0.366,
        0.146,
        0.207,
        0.203
      ],
      "noIndexMedianMs": 57.217,
      "indexMedianMs": 0.215,
      "speedup": 266.13
    },
    "offset50000": {
      "noIndexSamplesMs": [
        230.025,
        227.108,
        191.025,
        183.211,
        178.795,
        126.075,
        132.155,
        127.478,
        120.407,
        126.377,
        123.691,
        115.336,
        119.425,
        119.952,
        120.519
      ],
      "indexSamplesMs": [
        6.437,
        10.281,
        11.446,
        7.55,
        8.74,
        5.219,
        5.244,
        5.063,
        5.215,
        4.835,
        5.165,
        5.278,
        5.169,
        5.181,
        4.767
      ],
      "noIndexMedianMs": 126.377,
      "indexMedianMs": 5.219,
      "speedup": 24.21
    },
    "insert10000Rows": {
      "noIndexSamplesMs": [
        47.392,
        56.38,
        58.991,
        80.918,
        46.37,
        34.132,
        36.737,
        37.678,
        37.218,
        38.92,
        32.183,
        35.237,
        34.152,
        36.031,
        34.256
      ],
      "indexSamplesMs": [
        57.039,
        65.393,
        90.559,
        54.394,
        67.488,
        42.624,
        42.795,
        44.224,
        43.115,
        47.013,
        44.017,
        43.637,
        42.657,
        43.835,
        43.25
      ],
      "noIndexMedianMs": 37.218,
      "indexMedianMs": 44.017,
      "extraMicrosecondsPerUser": 0.68
    },
    "correctness": {
      "initialOrderMatchesEachRound": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "finalCountsMatchEachRound": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "finalOrderMatchesEachRound": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ]
    }
  },
  "tenUserBursts": {
    "distinctTimestamps": 50000,
    "indexBytesEachRound": [
      4751360,
      4751360,
      4751360
    ],
    "indexBytesPerInitialUser": 9.503,
    "indexBytesAfter50000InsertsEachRound": [
      5603328,
      5603328,
      5603328
    ],
    "firstPage": {
      "noIndexSamplesMs": [
        113.795,
        129.772,
        121.759,
        114.103,
        107.905,
        76.321,
        76.417,
        74.491,
        73.517,
        75.56,
        75.307,
        74.247,
        73.836,
        74.131,
        76.213
      ],
      "indexSamplesMs": [
        1.134,
        0.219,
        0.24,
        0.7,
        0.219,
        0.286,
        0.19,
        0.269,
        0.244,
        0.212,
        0.228,
        0.196,
        0.237,
        0.237,
        0.191
      ],
      "noIndexMedianMs": 76.213,
      "indexMedianMs": 0.237,
      "speedup": 321.57
    },
    "offset50000": {
      "noIndexSamplesMs": [
        221.554,
        235.467,
        327.723,
        220.735,
        219.383,
        139.801,
        142.349,
        136.331,
        143.815,
        149.221,
        137.129,
        133.334,
        133.841,
        132.927,
        139.428
      ],
      "indexSamplesMs": [
        14.06,
        15.705,
        12.723,
        12.931,
        12.787,
        7.385,
        7.884,
        7.219,
        7.374,
        7.475,
        7.951,
        7.783,
        7.626,
        7.465,
        7.622
      ],
      "noIndexMedianMs": 142.349,
      "indexMedianMs": 7.783,
      "speedup": 18.29
    },
    "insert10000Rows": {
      "noIndexSamplesMs": [
        52.854,
        59.003,
        62.892,
        70.446,
        70.98,
        32.716,
        33.745,
        32.633,
        34.996,
        34.804,
        43.5,
        33.932,
        32.596,
        35.148,
        34.663
      ],
      "indexSamplesMs": [
        61.26,
        68.779,
        58.442,
        60.291,
        100.505,
        38.469,
        39.399,
        39.874,
        39.556,
        40.619,
        40.819,
        42.759,
        40.281,
        39.762,
        41.015
      ],
      "noIndexMedianMs": 34.996,
      "indexMedianMs": 40.819,
      "extraMicrosecondsPerUser": 0.582
    },
    "correctness": {
      "initialOrderMatchesEachRound": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "finalCountsMatchEachRound": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "finalOrderMatchesEachRound": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ]
    }
  },
  "decision": {
    "status": "accepted_by_explicit_user_tradeoff",
    "productionVariant": "timestamp-only created_at DESC index accepted; compound index rejected and not present in production",
    "reason": "After seeing the corrected representative cost, the user explicitly accepted 11,255,808 bytes and +0.680 us per inserted user for unique timestamps (24.21x-266.13x read gains), plus 4,751,360 bytes and +0.582 us per user for ten-user bursts (18.29x-321.57x read gains). This decision does not cover the compound index. The isolated representative A/B/C follow-up rejected the compound index: it regressed the unique-timestamp first page and materially increased disk/write cost."
  },
  "compoundRepresentativeABC": {
    "status": "rejected",
    "candidate": "created_at DESC, id DESC compound index versus the accepted created_at DESC index",
    "method": {
      "rowsPerDistribution": 500000,
      "independentTransactions": 3,
      "samplesPerTransactionAndShape": 5,
      "totalSamplesPerShape": 15,
      "warmupsPerTransactionAndShape": 1,
      "order": "A/B/C order rotated inside every transaction",
      "cleanup": "every transaction ended in ROLLBACK",
      "commonIndexes": "all tables have the same UUID primary-key index",
      "insertBatchRows": 10000,
      "timingIsolation": "canonical rerun after other CPU/PostgreSQL benchmark agents stopped"
    },
    "indexStorage": {
      "uniqueTimestamps": {
        "simpleBytesEachRound": [
          11255808,
          11255808,
          11255808
        ],
        "compoundBytesEachRound": [
          20275200,
          20275200,
          20275200
        ],
        "compoundMinusSimpleBytes": 9019392,
        "compoundToSimpleRatio": 1.8013,
        "compoundIncreasePercent": 80.131,
        "simpleBytesAfter50000InsertsEachRound": [
          13271040,
          13271040,
          13271040
        ],
        "compoundBytesAfter50000InsertsEachRound": [
          23920640,
          23920640,
          23920640
        ],
        "afterInsertCompoundIncreasePercent": 80.247
      },
      "tenUserBursts": {
        "simpleBytesEachRound": [
          4751360,
          4751360,
          4751360
        ],
        "compoundBytesEachRound": [
          20324352,
          20324352,
          20324352
        ],
        "compoundMinusSimpleBytes": 15572992,
        "compoundToSimpleRatio": 4.2776,
        "compoundIncreasePercent": 327.759,
        "simpleBytesAfter50000InsertsEachRound": [
          5603328,
          5603328,
          5603328
        ],
        "compoundBytesAfter50000InsertsEachRound": [
          24068096,
          24068096,
          24068096
        ],
        "afterInsertCompoundIncreasePercent": 329.532
      }
    },
    "uniqueTimestamps": {
      "firstPage": {
        "noIndexSamplesMs": [
          79.055,
          63.205,
          69.033,
          64.688,
          66.893,
          57.082,
          56,
          64.918,
          70.986,
          74.456,
          88.976,
          61.345,
          56.376,
          57.135,
          59.125
        ],
        "simpleSamplesMs": [
          0.237,
          0.124,
          0.231,
          0.256,
          0.15,
          0.37,
          0.138,
          0.219,
          0.186,
          0.141,
          0.509,
          0.167,
          0.279,
          0.175,
          0.138
        ],
        "compoundSamplesMs": [
          0.121,
          0.198,
          0.164,
          0.291,
          0.204,
          0.151,
          0.216,
          0.214,
          0.118,
          0.221,
          0.477,
          0.214,
          0.164,
          0.106,
          0.194
        ],
        "noIndexMedianMs": 64.688,
        "simpleMedianMs": 0.186,
        "compoundMedianMs": 0.198,
        "compoundRegressionVsSimplePercent": 6.452
      },
      "offset50000": {
        "noIndexSamplesMs": [
          133.653,
          122.937,
          165.654,
          154.255,
          255.245,
          124.888,
          125.983,
          139.393,
          140.968,
          137.235,
          151.742,
          143.292,
          137.627,
          147.725,
          137.94
        ],
        "simpleSamplesMs": [
          6.273,
          5.542,
          5.288,
          10.254,
          6.294,
          4.821,
          5.034,
          5.457,
          5.628,
          5.614,
          15.465,
          5.859,
          5.174,
          5.198,
          5.096
        ],
        "compoundSamplesMs": [
          5.575,
          3.119,
          3.254,
          8.087,
          3.706,
          3.137,
          3.406,
          3.505,
          3.371,
          4.983,
          4.168,
          4.069,
          2.931,
          3.018,
          3.219
        ],
        "noIndexMedianMs": 139.393,
        "simpleMedianMs": 5.542,
        "compoundMedianMs": 3.406,
        "compoundSpeedupVsSimple": 1.627
      },
      "insert10000Rows": {
        "noIndexSamplesMs": [
          41.324,
          42.365,
          34.69,
          37.787,
          38.282,
          49.078,
          54.823,
          58.893,
          40.822,
          56.537,
          45.011,
          38.21,
          42.21,
          35.842,
          36.346
        ],
        "simpleSamplesMs": [
          54.828,
          48.465,
          42.161,
          45.736,
          58.347,
          102.65,
          71.567,
          64.681,
          56.949,
          55.432,
          55.426,
          46.866,
          47.472,
          46.171,
          46.097
        ],
        "compoundSamplesMs": [
          53.643,
          51.835,
          69.438,
          44.606,
          45.863,
          65.229,
          55.378,
          56.733,
          48.836,
          47.771,
          66.354,
          47.254,
          58.389,
          44.03,
          43.741
        ],
        "noIndexMedianMs": 41.324,
        "simpleMedianMs": 54.828,
        "compoundMedianMs": 51.835,
        "simpleExtraMicrosecondsPerUserVsNoIndex": 1.3504,
        "compoundExtraMicrosecondsPerUserVsNoIndex": 1.0511,
        "compoundDeltaMicrosecondsPerUserVsSimple": -0.2993
      }
    },
    "tenUserBursts": {
      "firstPage": {
        "noIndexSamplesMs": [
          97.536,
          83.007,
          82.563,
          77.801,
          81.854,
          80.281,
          84.272,
          86.625,
          117.336,
          91.597,
          78.241,
          100.035,
          73.378,
          76.37,
          73.884
        ],
        "simpleSamplesMs": [
          0.22,
          0.124,
          0.238,
          0.371,
          0.146,
          0.231,
          0.157,
          0.612,
          0.368,
          0.436,
          0.276,
          0.133,
          0.545,
          0.224,
          0.154
        ],
        "compoundSamplesMs": [
          0.11,
          0.163,
          0.343,
          0.156,
          0.192,
          0.132,
          0.206,
          0.24,
          0.175,
          0.486,
          0.134,
          0.158,
          0.137,
          0.106,
          0.235
        ],
        "noIndexMedianMs": 82.563,
        "simpleMedianMs": 0.231,
        "compoundMedianMs": 0.163,
        "compoundSpeedupVsSimple": 1.417
      },
      "offset50000": {
        "noIndexSamplesMs": [
          181.149,
          185.834,
          155.003,
          151.478,
          153.175,
          139.144,
          140.267,
          213.158,
          188.745,
          190.545,
          184.289,
          159.779,
          156.309,
          160.642,
          157.767
        ],
        "simpleSamplesMs": [
          8.038,
          8.418,
          7.489,
          7.892,
          9.026,
          7.378,
          7.724,
          8.3,
          8.486,
          11.09,
          10.755,
          7.569,
          7.527,
          7.927,
          7.424
        ],
        "compoundSamplesMs": [
          4.191,
          3.245,
          3.386,
          3.44,
          3.327,
          3.745,
          3.893,
          4.017,
          4.171,
          4.551,
          7.326,
          3.198,
          3.402,
          3.314,
          3.317
        ],
        "noIndexMedianMs": 159.779,
        "simpleMedianMs": 7.927,
        "compoundMedianMs": 3.44,
        "compoundSpeedupVsSimple": 2.304
      },
      "insert10000Rows": {
        "noIndexSamplesMs": [
          56.852,
          67.311,
          35.277,
          41.769,
          38.984,
          43.076,
          40.612,
          46.572,
          41.514,
          38.331,
          56.728,
          39.23,
          36.724,
          36.912,
          36.015
        ],
        "simpleSamplesMs": [
          75.665,
          73.424,
          43.871,
          43.275,
          43.638,
          59.345,
          50.214,
          44.475,
          40.879,
          46.694,
          65.48,
          42.844,
          44.616,
          44.221,
          42.984
        ],
        "compoundSamplesMs": [
          48.496,
          59.438,
          42.891,
          43.67,
          45.941,
          70.587,
          57.743,
          49.954,
          48.921,
          57.737,
          58.111,
          45.346,
          49.969,
          43.602,
          45.851
        ],
        "noIndexMedianMs": 40.612,
        "simpleMedianMs": 44.475,
        "compoundMedianMs": 48.921,
        "simpleExtraMicrosecondsPerUserVsNoIndex": 0.3863,
        "compoundExtraMicrosecondsPerUserVsNoIndex": 0.8309,
        "compoundDeltaMicrosecondsPerUserVsSimple": 0.4446
      }
    },
    "correctness": {
      "initialOrderMatchesEachRound": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "finalCountsMatchEachRound": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ],
      "finalOrderMatchesEachRound": [
        true,
        true,
        true
      ]
    },
    "decision": "rejected: versus the accepted narrow index, the compound index regressed the common unique-timestamp first page by 6.45%, enlarged the btree by 80.13%-327.76%, and added 0.445 us/user to burst inserts. Its 1.63x-2.30x deep-page gains do not pass the no-regression resource gate."
  }
}